3种支原体检测方法的比较Comparison of three methods for determination of mycoplasmas
卢勇,贾继宗,唐静,叶祥忠
LU Yong,JIA Ji-zong,TANG Jing,YE Xiang-zhong
摘要(Abstract):
目的比较PCR法、酶法和DNA荧光染色法3种支原体检测方法的灵敏度。方法支原体阳性的BSR细胞培养上清10倍系列稀释后(10-1~10-8),接种至支原体阴性的Vero细胞上,盲传培养5代,每代每个稀释度的样品分别采用PCR法、酶法和DNA荧光染色法检测支原体,并以支原体阴性的Vero细胞作为阴性对照。结果 10倍系列稀释的阳性样品盲传1代,PCR法能检测到10-4,酶法和DNA荧光染色法能检测到10-3;盲传2代,3种方法均能检测到10-4;盲传3代后,3种方法均能检测到10-5,且检测的支原体滴度不随盲传代次的增加而增加。结论待检样本盲传3代后的支原体用3种方法均可检出,检测灵敏度一致。PCR法与酶法检测支原体准确、快速、简便易行,可作为DNA荧光染色法(支原体检测的金标准)的补充手段。
Objective To compare PCR, enzymic method and DNA fluorescent staining for determination of mycoplasmas.Methods Mycoplasma-positive BSR cell culture supernatant was 10-fold serially diluted(10-1 ~ 10-8) and inoculated to mycoplasma-negative Vero cells for five blind passages. The samples of various passages at each dilution were determined for mycoplasma by PCR, enzymic method and DNA fluorescent staining, using mycoplasma-negative Vero cells as control.Results After one blind passage, mycoplasma was detected in the positive samples at a dilution of 10-4by PCR, while in those at a dilution of 10-3by enzymic method and DNA fluorescent method. After two blind passages, mycoplasma was detected in samples at a dilution of 10-4by three methods. However, after three blind passages, mycoplasma was detected in samples at a dilution of 10-5by three methods, of which the titer showed no increase with the increasing passage.Conclusion After the samples were subjected to three blind passages, mycoplasma was detected by each of the three methods with consistent sensitivities. PCR and enzymic method were accurate, rapid and simple for determination of mycoplasma, which might be used as a supplement of DNA fluorescent staining.
关键词(KeyWords):
支原体;聚合酶链反应;酶法;DNA荧光染色法
Mycoplasma;Polymerase chain reaction;Enzymic method;DNA fluorescent staining
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author):
卢勇,贾继宗,唐静,叶祥忠
LU Yong,JIA Ji-zong,TANG Jing,YE Xiang-zhong
DOI: 10.13200/j.cnki.cjb.001091
参考文献(References):
- [1]Morozkin ES,Sil'nikov VN,Rykova EY,et al.Extracellular DNA in culture of primary and transformed cells,infected and not infected with mycoplasma[J].Bull Exp Biol Med,2009,147(1):63-65.
- [2]Hu MD,Tang SE.Application of PCR for detection of mycoplasma contamination in cell culture or biological products[J].Foreign Med Sci(Section of bilogics for prophylaxis,diagnosis and therapy),1996,19(3):110-114.(in Chinese).胡孟冬,唐颂恩.应用PCR技术检测细胞培养或生物制品中的支原体污染[J].国外医学:预防、诊断、治疗用生物制品分册,1996,19(3):110-114.
- [3]Ni HX,Chen LM,Zhang L.Species-specific PCR for identification of common contaminant mycoplasma in cell culture[J].J Beihua Univ(Nat Sci),2007,8(6):510-512.(in Chinese)倪红霞,陈立梅,张雷.支原体种属特异性PCR引物的设计及对细胞培养物支原体的检测[J].北华大学学报(自然科学版),2007,8(6):510-512.
- [4]Muhlrad,Peleg I,Robertson JA,et al.Acetate kinase activity in mycoplasmas[J].J Bacteriol,1981,147(1):271-273.
- [5]Kahane I,Razin S,Muhlrad A.Possible role of acetate kinase in ATP generation in Mycoplasma hominis and Acholeplasma laidlawii[J].FEMS Microbiol Lett,1978,3(1):143-145.
- [6]Rottem S,Razin S.Uptake and utilization of acetate by mycoplasmas[J].J Gen Microbiol,1967,48(1):53-63.
- [7]Taylor RR,Mohan K,Miles RJ.Diversity of energy-yielding substrates and metabolism in avian mycoplasmas[J].Vet Microbiol,1996,51(3-4):291-304.
- [8]Rottem S.Sterols and acylated proteins in mycoplasmas[J].Biochem Biophys Res Commun,2002,292(5):1289-1292.
- [9]Golding EM,Teague WE Jr,Dobson GP.Adjustment of K'to varying p H and p Mg for the creatine kinase,adenylate kinase and ATP hydrolysis equilibria permitting quantitative bioenergetic assessment[J].J Exp Biol,1995,198(Pt 8):1775-1782.
- [10]Teague WE Jr,Golding EM,Dobson GP.Adjustment of K'for the creatine kinase,adenylate kinase and ATP hydrolysis equilibria to varying temperature and ionic strength[J].J Exp Biol,1996,199(Pt 2):509-512.
- [11]Verhoef V,Germain G,Fridland A,et al.Adenosine phosphorylase activity in mycoplasma-free growth media for mammalian cells[J].Exp Cell Res,1983,149(1):37-44.
- [12]Limb DI,Wheat PF,Hastings JG,et al.Antimicrobial susceptibility testing of mycoplasmas by ATP bioluminescence[J].J Med Microbiol,1991,35(2):89-92.13]Chinese Pharmacopoeia Commission.Pharmacopoeia of People's Republic of China(VolⅢ)[S].Beijing:China Med Sci Press,2010:Append 93.(in Chinese)国家药典委员会.中华人民共和国药典(三部)[S].北京:中国医药科技出版社,2010:附录93.
- [14]Jiang DC,Gao G,Zhang N,et al.Comparison of PCR,DNA flourescent and cultivation used for detection of mycoplasmas[J].Chin J Biologicals,1995,8(4):179-181.(in Chinese)姜典才,高光,张宁,等.PCR法、DNA荧光染色法与培养法在支原体检测中的比较[J].中国生物制品学杂志,1995,8(4):179-181.
- [15]Ying C,Liu C,Wang HG,et al.The progress of the detection and identification of mycoplasma contamination[J].China Poult,2012,34(23):46-49.(in Chinese)英聪,刘灿,王海光,等.支原体污染的检测及鉴定方法研究进展[J].中国家禽,2012,34(23):46-49.
- [16]Chen B,Xu CL,Liu GF,et al.The validation and statistical evaluation of the method for the detection of mycoplasmas in biological products[J].Chin J Biologicals,2005,18(1):62-64.(in Chinese)陈波,徐程林,刘桂芳,等.生物制品中支原体检定方法的验证及统计学评价[J].中国生物制品学杂志,2005,18(1):62-64.